Finance Automation Buyer's Guide: How CFOs Evaluate AI Solutions in 2026

The definitive framework for CFOs evaluating AI finance automation platforms—from RFP templates to ROI calculations, vendor scorecards, and implementation timelines.

Feb 3, 2026 · 15 min read

TL;DR: CFOs evaluating finance automation platforms face 200+ vendors, unclear ROI claims, and implementation risk. This buyer’s guide provides a decision framework: 8 evaluation criteria, vendor scorecard template, RFP questions, total cost of ownership model, and a 90-day implementation roadmap. Use this to cut evaluation time from 6 months to 6 weeks and avoid costly vendor mistakes.

The finance automation market exploded from $8B in 2023 to $18B in 2026—and with that growth came vendor proliferation, feature overlap, and increasingly confusing marketing claims. CFOs now face a paradox: automation promises to save time, but evaluating automation platforms consumes months of team bandwidth.

This guide cuts through the noise. Whether you’re automating AP, AR, reconciliation, or full close processes, you’ll learn exactly what to evaluate, which questions separate real solutions from vaporware, and how to build an ROI case that gets board approval.

The Stakes: Why Vendor Selection Matters

Bad Vendor Selection Costs

Direct Costs:

Indirect Costs:

Real Example: A $75M SaaS company chose an AP automation vendor based on price alone. After 8 months and $120k spent, they abandoned implementation due to poor ERP integration. They ultimately paid more by choosing the cheapest option.

Good Vendor Selection Delivers

The 8 Critical Evaluation Criteria

1. ERP/Accounting System Integration Depth

Why It Matters: Surface-level integrations create more work, not less. True automation requires deep, bidirectional ERP connectivity.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Scorecard Weight: 25%—this is foundational

2. AI Accuracy & Learning Capability

Why It Matters: 85% accuracy means your team still manually corrects 1 in 7 invoices. 98% accuracy transforms workflows.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Testing Method: Submit 20 of your actual invoices (diverse formats) and measure:

Scorecard Weight: 20%—accuracy dictates ROI

3. Exception Handling & Human-in-the-Loop Design

Why It Matters: No AI is 100% accurate. The difference between good and bad platforms is how they handle the 5-15% of transactions that need human judgment.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Demo Request: Show an invoice with a formatting issue and walk through exception handling.

Scorecard Weight: 15%

4. Workflow Flexibility & Approval Routing

Why It Matters: Every company has unique approval policies. Rigid platforms force you to change your processes instead of adapting to them.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Use Case to Test: “We need invoices >$10k to route to the controller, >$50k to the CFO, and any construction materials to also route to our operations director regardless of amount. Can you configure that?”

Scorecard Weight: 10%

5. Security, Compliance & Audit Readiness

Why It Matters: Finance automation platforms access your most sensitive data. Security failures can be catastrophic.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Checklist:

Scorecard Weight: 15%—non-negotiables here

6. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

Why It Matters: Headline pricing hides implementation costs, integration fees, training, and ongoing maintenance. TCO reveals true costs.

TCO Components:

Cost CategoryTypical RangeQuestions to Ask
Platform License$500-$5,000/monthPer-user or per-transaction? Price increases as we scale?
Implementation$5,000-$50,000One-time or phased? What’s included vs additional consulting?
ERP Integration$2,000-$25,000One-time or annual maintenance fee? Who owns integration updates?
Training$2,000-$10,000Included or extra? Ongoing training for new hires?
SupportIncluded or $500-$2,000/monthSLA for response times? Phone/email/chat? Dedicated CSM?
Customization$5,000-$50,000What requires custom dev work? Hourly rates?

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

TCO Calculation Template:

Year 1:
- Platform license: $X × 12 = $A
- Implementation: $B
- Integration: $C
- Training: $D
- TOTAL YEAR 1: $A + $B + $C + $D = $Y1

Year 2-3 (annual):
- Platform license: $X × 12 = $A
- Support/maintenance: $E
- TOTAL YEAR 2-3: $A + $E = $Y2

3-Year TCO: $Y1 + ($Y2 × 2) = $TCO

Scorecard Weight: 10%

7. Implementation Timeline & Change Management

Why It Matters: A 12-month implementation timeline means a 12-month delay on ROI. Fast, low-friction implementations win.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Ideal Implementation Timeline:

Scorecard Weight: 10%

8. Vendor Stability & Roadmap

Why It Matters: Choosing a vendor that gets acquired, runs out of funding, or pivots away from your use case creates risk.

Questions to Ask:

Red Flags:

Due Diligence:

Scorecard Weight: 5%—only matters if other criteria are met

The Vendor Evaluation Scorecard

Use this template to score vendors objectively:

VENDOR: _______________  |  EVALUATED BY: _______________  |  DATE: _______________

Criteria                          | Weight | Score (1-10) | Weighted Score | Notes
----------------------------------|--------|--------------|----------------|-------
1. ERP Integration Depth          | 25%    |              |                |
2. AI Accuracy & Learning         | 20%    |              |                |
3. Exception Handling             | 15%    |              |                |
4. Workflow Flexibility           | 10%    |              |                |
5. Security & Compliance          | 15%    |              |                |
6. Total Cost of Ownership        | 10%    |              |                |
7. Implementation Timeline        | 10%    |              |                |
8. Vendor Stability               | 5%     |              |                |
----------------------------------|--------|--------------|----------------|-------
TOTAL                             | 100%   |              |                |

Weighted Score Calculation: (Score × Weight) summed across all criteria

Scoring Guidance:

Decision Threshold:

RFP Questions Template

Use these questions in your RFP or vendor evaluations:

Integration & Technical

  1. Describe your integration with [our ERP]. Is it native API or third-party?
  2. What data can you read from our ERP? What can you write?
  3. How do you handle ERP updates and version changes?
  4. What’s required from our IT team during implementation?

AI & Accuracy

  1. What’s your extraction accuracy on invoices/payments/reconciliation?
  2. How does accuracy improve over time as the AI learns?
  3. How do you handle invoice formats you’ve never seen before?
  4. Can we test your AI on 20 of our actual invoices during evaluation?

Workflow & Approvals

  1. Describe how approval routing works. Can we configure multi-level, conditional approvals?
  2. Where do users approve transactions? (Email, Slack, mobile app, portal?)
  3. How do you handle approver out-of-office scenarios?

Security & Compliance

  1. Are you SOC 2 Type II certified? Can you provide the report?
  2. How do you encrypt data at rest and in transit?
  3. Describe your audit trail capabilities.
  4. What’s your uptime SLA and disaster recovery plan?

Pricing & TCO

  1. Provide detailed pricing for Year 1 and Year 2-3 (all-in costs).
  2. What’s included in standard implementation vs additional services?
  3. How does pricing scale as our transaction volume grows?
  4. Are there additional fees we should be aware of?

Implementation & Support

  1. What’s the realistic timeline from signature to go-live?
  2. How many hours will our team need to invest?
  3. Describe your training and change management support.
  4. What’s your support model? (SLA, hours, channels, dedicated CSM?)

References & Roadmap

  1. Provide 3-5 referenceable customers in our industry and size range.
  2. What’s on your 12-month product roadmap?
  3. What’s your customer retention rate?

Building the ROI Business Case

ROI Components

Savings (Annual):

  1. Labor cost reduction

    • Hours saved per month × $40-$80/hour (loaded cost) × 12
    • Example: 60 hours/month saved × $60/hour = $43,200/year

  2. Error reduction

    • Current error rate × cost per error × annual transaction volume
    • Example: 5% error rate × $150/error × 2,000 transactions = $15,000/year

  3. Faster close savings

    • Days saved on month-end close × controller/CFO daily cost
    • Example: 5 days saved × $800/day = $4,000/month = $48,000/year

  4. Early payment discount capture

    • % of invoices eligible × 2% discount × annual spend
    • Example: 30% of $5M spend × 2% = $30,000/year

  5. Redeployed talent value

    • FTEs redeployed to strategic work × annual salary
    • Example: 0.5 FTE × $70,000 salary = $35,000/year value creation

Costs (3-Year):

ROI Formula:

ROI % = [(Total 3-Year Savings - Total 3-Year Costs) / Total 3-Year Costs] × 100

Payback Period = Total Year 1 Costs / (Monthly Savings × 12)

Example Business Case

Company Profile:

Current State Costs:

Automation Costs:

Automation Savings:

3-Year ROI:

Implementation Roadmap (90 Days)

Pre-Implementation (Weeks -2 to 0)

Month 1: Foundation (Weeks 1-4)

Month 2: Pilot (Weeks 5-8)

Month 3: Full Rollout (Weeks 9-12)

Success Metrics (30/60/90 Days)

30 Days:

60 Days:

90 Days:

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Choosing Based on Price Alone

The cheapest platform often costs more due to poor integration, low accuracy, and extended implementations.

Fix: Evaluate TCO over 3 years, not just year 1 platform costs.

2. Skipping the Pilot Phase

Going all-in on day 1 creates risk and reduces team buy-in.

Fix: Pilot with 20-30% of transactions for 3-4 weeks before full rollout.

3. Ignoring Change Management

Even great technology fails without user adoption.

Fix: Involve team in vendor selection, communicate benefits, train thoroughly.

4. Over-Trusting Vendor Demos

Demos showcase best-case scenarios, not real-world performance.

Fix: Demand testing on YOUR actual data (invoices, reconciliations, etc.)

5. No Clear Success Metrics

Without baseline metrics, you can’t prove ROI.

Fix: Document current-state time/cost before implementation. Measure monthly post-launch.

6. Automating Broken Processes

AI automation on top of inefficient workflows just creates faster chaos.

Fix: Map ideal-state processes first, then automate.

FAQs

Q: How long should vendor evaluation take? A: 4-8 weeks. Longer evaluations rarely yield better decisions—decision paralysis just delays ROI.

Q: Should we build or buy? A: Buy unless you’re a FinTech with engineering resources to spare. Building custom automation costs 5-10x more and takes 18-24 months vs 6-8 weeks for proven platforms.

Q: Can we automate just one process (e.g., AP only)? A: Yes—start with your biggest pain point. Most companies begin with AP automation and expand to AR/reconciliation after seeing results.

Q: What if our ERP isn’t supported? A: Major ERPs (NetSuite, SAP, QuickBooks, Sage, Xero) are universally supported. For niche ERPs, ask vendors about custom integration costs and timelines.

Q: How do we handle vendor lock-in concerns? A: Prioritize platforms with data export capabilities and API access. Avoid vendors who hold your data hostage. Ask about offboarding process during evaluation.

Q: What transaction volume justifies automation? A: Generally 200+ monthly transactions (AP + AR combined) or 20+ hours/month of manual finance work. Below that, automation ROI may not justify costs.

Your Next Steps

Week 1: Internal Alignment

  1. Audit current workflows—document time, costs, error rates
  2. Identify pain points and prioritize (AP, AR, reconciliation, close process)
  3. Calculate baseline ROI (current state costs)
  4. Get executive buy-in for evaluation process

Week 2-3: Vendor Research

  1. Shortlist 3-5 vendors based on your ERP and use case
  2. Send RFP with questions from this guide
  3. Review responses against evaluation scorecard
  4. Narrow to 2-3 finalists

Week 4-6: Deep Evaluation

  1. Schedule demos with finalists (use YOUR data, not generic demos)
  2. Request customer references and call them
  3. Test AI accuracy on 20+ of your actual invoices
  4. Complete vendor scorecards
  5. Calculate 3-year TCO for each finalist

Week 7-8: Decision & Contracting

  1. Select vendor (8.0+ scorecard score recommended)
  2. Negotiate contract (pricing, SLAs, support, exit terms)
  3. Plan implementation timeline
  4. Assign internal project lead

Week 9-12+: Implementation Follow the 90-day roadmap above.

Ready to evaluate finance automation platforms? Use this guide as your framework. If you’re evaluating AI agents for AP, AR, or reconciliation, ProcIndex offers a free ROI calculator and process audit—see exactly what automation could save your team.

For related deep dives, check out our guides on AP automation for manufacturing CFOs and bank reconciliation automation.

More from ProcIndex